
For most expats, an independent mortgage broker beats walking into a single bank. A bank can only offer you its own products, while a broker compares the whole market, 15 to 30 or more lenders, and knows which of them actually say yes to foreign income, a non-permanent contract or the 30% ruling. Below is the real difference between the two, when a bank can still work, and how to keep the advice fee sensible.
Bank or broker: the core difference
A Dutch bank will happily advise you on a mortgage, but only on its own mortgage. ABN AMRO advises on ABN AMRO products, ING on ING products. That is not independent advice, it is a sales conversation about one shelf in one shop.
An independent mortgage broker (a hypotheekadviseur) is not tied to a single lender. They compare many lenders on rate, conditions and, crucially for expats, on who will accept your situation at all. Same you, same income, but a very different maximum mortgage and a very different rate depending on which lender you land at. That comparison is the whole value.
Why this matters more for expats
If you have a permanent Dutch contract and a euro salary, a bank might serve you perfectly well. Most expats are not in that box, and that is exactly where a broker earns their fee:
- Foreign or non-euro income. Only some lenders accept it, and they each treat it differently. A broker knows which ones and how to present it.
- A temporary or new contract. Many lenders want a permanent contract or an employer's statement of intent. A broker knows who is flexible.
- The 30% ruling. It lifts your net pay but not your gross-based maximum mortgage, and lenders handle it differently. See the 30% ruling and mortgage guide.
- Savings or assets held abroad. Some lenders count them, some do not.
Go to one bank and you get one answer. If that bank happens to be strict on foreign income, you might conclude you cannot borrow much, when another lender would have said yes to far more.
Is mortgage advice regulated in the Netherlands?
Yes, and it is worth knowing. Every mortgage adviser in the Netherlands must be registered with the AFM, the Dutch financial markets authority, and advisers are supervised by the AFM and the Dutch Central Bank ( AFM). Before you commit, an adviser gives you a comparison card (the Vergelijkingskaart) that sets out their services, how independent they are, and what they cost. Ask for it, and check that the adviser genuinely compares the market rather than a short list of preferred lenders.
What does mortgage advice cost?
Independent advice is not free, and that is fine, because it routinely saves you far more than it costs by finding a better rate or a lender who says yes. The one thing to avoid is a percentage-of-mortgage fee. On a €400,000 mortgage a 1% fee is €4,000, for work that is much the same as on a smaller loan. A clear fixed fee, agreed in advance, is almost always the better deal. With Property Cloud, buying advice and mortgage advice combined are capped at a fixed €4,750, so there are no surprises.
How I handle the mortgage side
I am a buying agent, and I package the financing into the same service so the home, the price and the mortgage all line up. The regulated mortgage advice is handled by my mortgage partner, EB Mortgages, a specialist with around 20 years in Dutch mortgages who advises expats across the country. Together we compare more than 20 lenders to find the one that says yes to your situation on the best terms, foreign income and the 30% ruling included.
The first consultation is free and there is no obligation, so the easiest place to start is a quick chat about what you can actually borrow. You can also read more on my expat mortgage page.
How much can you actually borrow?
Start with a free, no-obligation mortgage check. We compare 20+ lenders, including foreign-income and 30% ruling options.
So, broker or bank?
If you have a permanent Dutch contract, a euro salary and time to shop around, a bank can work. If you are an expat with foreign income, a newer contract, the 30% ruling, or you simply want the best rate across the market without doing the legwork, an independent broker is almost always the stronger move. The comparison alone usually pays for the advice several times over.
Frequently asked questions
Is a mortgage broker better than a bank for expats?
Usually, yes. A bank only offers its own mortgage, while an independent broker compares many lenders and knows which ones accept foreign income, temporary contracts and the 30% ruling. For a standard permanent Dutch contract and euro salary, a bank can also work well.
Do mortgage advisers charge a fee?
Yes. Independent advice is paid, but it usually saves more than it costs. Prefer a clear fixed fee agreed in advance over a percentage of the mortgage, which gets expensive on larger loans for much the same work.
Can a broker get me a Dutch mortgage on foreign income?
Often, yes. A number of lenders accept foreign and non-euro income, but they each treat it differently, so the choice of lender matters. A broker who does expat mortgages daily knows which ones to approach and how to present your income.
Is mortgage advice regulated in the Netherlands?
Yes. Every adviser must be registered with the AFM and is supervised by the AFM and the Dutch Central Bank. Ask for the comparison card (Vergelijkingskaart), which shows the adviser's services, independence and costs before you commit.
Broker or bank for the 30% ruling?
A broker, in most cases. The 30% ruling raises your net income rather than your maximum mortgage, and lenders apply it differently, so comparing across the market matters more than with a standard salary.
Not sure which lender fits your situation?
Start with a free, no-obligation chat. I'll line up the buying advice and the mortgage in one, so the home, the price and the financing all fit together.
Read next: the expat mortgage in the Netherlands, how the 30% ruling affects your borrowing, and the full buying-agent service.
Julian Buckmaster
After 20 years of property experience in South Africa and other English speaking territories' at Broker/.owner level and corporate positions in residential, commercial and property management with international Franchise brands, I've found my niche in the vibrant, exciting brain port of Eindhoven and surrounds. Property Cloud is a specialist expat advisory agency for all things real estate, from securing long term rentals to buying your first home in your newly chosen city and even investment property advice, we have all the bases covered with the right advice at the right price. Having made the journey myself I have a heart for the expat and all the changes one experiences when you first arrive, let me make that a little easier by making your accomodation needs as easy as our slogan, 'Property Cloud, soft landings for expats'. For an obligation free consultation mail me on julian@propertycloudagent.nl I'll be happy to refer you to our 100's of happy clients from all over the world.
Questions about your move?
Message Julian on WhatsApp. He usually replies within the hour.
WhatsApp Julian